News

Mamdani’s Free-Bus Promise Hits the Wall: One in Five New York Riders Can’t Afford Fares as the MTA Plans Another Hike

  |   By Liz Peek Staff
An MTA bus displaying a Fare Required sign drives through snow in Brooklyn, New York City

Photo by Michael M. Santiago/Getty Images

Zohran Mamdani ran for mayor on a promise to make New York City’s buses free. A year later, the buses still cost money, and the Metropolitan Transportation Authority is lining up another fare hike, even as a new survey finds one in five riders say they already can’t afford the ride.

As Townhall reported, citing the New York Post, the MTA plans to raise fares in March 2027 as part of a push to boost fare and toll revenue by 4%. A matching increase in the $3 base fare would bring it to $3.12, though the agency has not yet proposed a specific new subway and bus fare, and the hike still needs board approval.

The timing could hardly be worse for the “free buses” crowd. A new survey by the Community Service Society, an anti-poverty nonprofit, found that some 20% of riders say they can’t afford the fare. Nearly three in 10 said that, despite struggling to pay, they earn too much to qualify for the city’s half-price Fair Fares program.

The group’s answer? Spend more. It suggested expanding Fair Fares eligibility from 200% of the federal poverty level to 300%.

State Comptroller Thomas DiNapoli’s office has said the authority could rein in costs to keep its spending closer to its operating revenue. The MTA is still facing a $900 million budget deficit by 2030, even after counting the planned fare hikes in 2027 and another in 2029. The Post also noted that the agency paid out $1.5 billion in overtime last year and was on pace to top that total by September.

Fare evasion makes it worse. According to The New York Times, fare beating cost the MTA $1 billion in 2024, and Spectrum News has reported that as many as half of the city’s bus riders don’t pay at all. Paying customers, in other words, are being asked to cover for the riders who skip the fare box, and the bill keeps climbing.

Rather than tighten its belt, the MTA appears to be eyeing Washington. According to the Post, the agency wrote a policy brief after the midterms that read like a pitch for a federal bailout once Democrats take control of Congress in January.

“Elections swing on more than just a few key issues, but voters have made themselves clear: they’re fed up with the federal government’s assault on cities,” the brief said.

“Mamdani promised free buses, and then MTA hikes fares. When will voters learn that nothing is free, and socialism isn’t affordable?” one New Yorker wrote on X. Spencer Pratt was blunter: “Commie Mamdani promised free buses. New Yorkers got fare hikes instead.”

It is a familiar arc for big-government promises. The giveaway is free on the campaign trail. Once the bills come due, someone has to pay, and in New York it is the straphanger who already can’t afford the ride.

Source: townhall.com