News

‘Explain the Math to Me’: Mamdani Pressed on How City-Run Grocery Stores Can Cut Prices 30% on Razor-Thin Margins, Answers With a Speech on a ‘Dignified Life’

  |   By Liz Peek Staff
New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani speaks at a news conference outside City Hall on Nov. 4, 2026

Photo by Andres Kudacki/Getty Images

New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani was handed a simple question about his signature plan for city-run grocery stores this week: how do the numbers work? He did not answer it.

At the New York Times DealBook Summit, DealBook founder Andrew Ross Sorkin pressed the socialist mayor on the math, Townhall reported. As Townhall described the exchange, grocery stores typically run on profit margins of just one to four percent. So how could a city-run store offer 30 percent discounts on major food items, and what would the subsidies needed to cover that gap do to the supermarkets competing down the street?

Mamdani skipped the arithmetic and went straight to political philosophy.

“I take a step back and I think about when society deems something necessary for the public, then we subsidize its creation and its operation,” Mamdani said. “We know that so much of what we rely on from the public sector is not being paid for at price, whether it be the subway or a public school or a library or sanitation. We have determined this is necessary.”

“And when I think about what is necessary for a dignified life in New York City and anywhere, frankly, it is very easy to come back to food because you cannot live without it,” he added.

In other words, the gap between the price on the shelf and the cost of putting the food there would be covered by subsidy. And subsidy means taxpayers.

The examples he picked do not help his case. As Townhall noted, the very services he held up as models “already struggle to deliver quality at a reasonable cost.” Is a city-run grocery aisle supposed to work better than the subway?

Mamdani then turned Sorkin’s challenge into a complaint about grocery prices.

“And when you were saying explain the math to me, in some ways, that’s the question that New Yorkers are asking themselves every day when they go to the grocery store,” he said. “Explain the math to me of how the same thing that I used to buy a couple of years ago has now skyrocketed in price.”

“We need to make it easier for them to actually be able to afford,” he said.

But the shopper does not escape the bill. Townhall put it bluntly: the plan amounts to “simply forcing New Yorkers to pay later by increasing their taxes.”

That is the whole economics problem in one exchange. A business that clears a few pennies on every dollar cannot knock 30 percent off its prices and stay open on its own. Somebody covers the difference, and in Mamdani’s model that somebody is the same New Yorker he says cannot afford groceries now.

Then there are the private supermarkets that pay rent, wages and taxes without a city check. They would be competing against a government store selling below cost. Nothing in Mamdani’s answer dealt with them either.

Asked to explain the math, the mayor of the country’s largest city delivered a speech about a “dignified life” instead. Let that sink in.

Source: townhall.com